A Sad Tale on “Tell A Story” Day

Today, April 27, 2016, is supposedly “Tell a Story Day”, so here’s mine. I’m sorry it’s a sad tale.

This is about a journalist I used to respect: Margaret Wente, who is currently a columnist for The Globe and Mail newspaper. Wente is described by her own editors as “controversial.”  I don’t always agree with her but I applaud her for taking some unpopular stands or expressing what might be considered politically incorrect opinions. What I don’t applaud her for is plagiarizing other people’s work. She did it in 2012, and she’s done it again. (Please follow the link at the end of the story for more details.)

The editors have posted an apology and let people know that corrections have been made. Corrections and apologies are often buried in the paper and many do not even see them. I expect that will be end of it. Business as usual: Wente will continue to be employed by The Globe and they’ll just hope that this will blow over; that everyone will move on. Wente is the one who should move on. But she isn’t.

Wente said in defending herself in 2012 that she was not a “serial plagiarist” but that there were folks who “just don’t like what I write” and were therefore attacking her work ethics.  She hasn’t said anything this time around and if her editors are doing the apologizing for her and correcting her mistakes, then why should she? Her story is being told for her.

This is not just a problem for Wente, but for The Globe as well. Or is it? No doubt, its readership is down, as is the case with many newspapers, and what better way to bring in readers than with a “controversial” writer? People will be looking to see if, nay, when, she will plagiarize again, and get away with it—again.

The state of journalism is not in disarray because of digital media, as some have suggested. It is in disarray though when editors keep defending writers who seem to have no issue with writing something that is so similar to someone else’s work that it cannot be called anything but plagiarism, and that writer, now caught in this web more than once, cannot be called anything but a “serial plagiarist.”

This story may have a happy ending for Wente, but it is not a good one for writers and how they should conduct themselves. She should resign (but likely won’t) or she should be fired (but likely won’t be.)

I am sad that a writer I once respected, and the editors of a paper that I love to read have let this play out the way it has. A sad tale for me, indeed.

This has been covered in many media outlets. One of the most informative for me was an interview done on the CBC program “As it Happens”  last night. Here is a link to the interview, and some snippets from other media outlets covering this issue.

http://tinyurl.com/h6lum2r

Advertisements

6 thoughts on “A Sad Tale on “Tell A Story” Day

  1. So timely with the Republican cinvention and Melania Trump’s speech plagerizing Michelle Obama’s. They say it only constitutes 3 % of the speech, but I can’t seem to find any copies of thw whole speech only the bits that are plagerized. So any thing that might have been worth reading has been overshadowed by the dishonesty of plagerizing

    1. Thank you, Veronica. I’d forgotten about this post and Wente’s situation. I am not sure, but would not be surprised, that she is still writing for The Globe and Mail. So there doesn’t appear to be any consequence for her actions. Nor will there be for Melania Trump and whoever “helped” with her sppech. There were some sites showing the full texts of both speeches. I think CBC.ca might have been one. A few paragraphs, about 7% are *very* similar, and it wasn’t plagiarism because, according to one woman on Trump’s team, “Michelle Obama didn’t invent the English language.”
      Thanks for the comment. We will talk soon.

  2. Excellent article. I hadn’t heard about this, but often wonder if any part of our online writing could be used by other authors, especially ones who are getting paid for writing. The outcome of this could set a new precedent. Let’s hope it does.

    1. I’m not sure where the original articles that Wente plagiarized were printed, but copying from online work is definitely easier. I have a friend who has had her blog posts copied and reposted in their entirety, right down to her name!
      Let’s hope Wente and The Globe have learned from this and her work will be better vetted before it’s published and IF she does it again, she will be OUT.

  3. Plagiarism is an easy way to go. On the other hand another writer may send a person off in a new direction–which of course is not plagiarism. Well done. Roy

    1. Thank you for your comment and compliment, Roy. Plagiarism is indeed an easy way to go, and the Internet has made it easier because it’s not always easy to trace a source. That’s where a writer has to do more research and due diligence to either attribute the comments or as you say, go off in another direction.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s